In short
What if my Bulgarian bank refuses a phishing refund citing gross negligence?
We challenge bank refusals based on “gross negligence” after phishing: we analyse the bank's evidence, draft a reasoned complaint and represent you before the Conciliation Commission for Payment Disputes and in court, including when the bank tries to claim the money back. You get an honest assessment of the strong and weak points of your case. The first consultation is free of charge.
Phishing is fraud through fake websites, text messages and e-mails: a “delivery” message, a page that looks like your online banking, or a link from a “buyer” on a classifieds platform. You enter your details and the fraudster orders a transfer. Then comes a short letter from the bank: “the transaction was confirmed with your security credentials; this is gross negligence”. Many people accept this as final, but the law says otherwise.
This page is about the gross negligence dispute. The general rules on unauthorised payments and the first steps are on our unauthorised transactions page. If the bank has refused to refund you, send us the refusal together with the text messages and we will tell you what can be done.
Phishing: why the transaction is, as a rule, unauthorised
In classic phishing you do not order a payment. You enter your details on a fake website and the fraudster uses them to order a transfer. Since you had no intention of paying that payee, the transaction is unauthorised under Art. 70(1) of the Payment Services and Payment Systems Act (Закон за платежните услуги и платежните системи, ЗПУПС).
The general protection then applies: the bank refunds the amount by the end of the next business day (Art. 79(1)), and you bear at most EUR 50 for transactions before you notified the bank. Gross negligence is the exception: if the bank proves it, the customer bears the whole loss, with no cap (Art. 80(3)).
I clicked a link in a text message. Have I lost my money?
Not automatically. Merely opening a link usually discloses no data. Even if you entered details, the bank must prove that doing so was grossly negligent in your specific situation. Your position is weaker if you installed a remote access program or ignored a clear warning.
What gross negligence means in bank fraud cases
The Act does not define the term. Bulgarian courts use the general civil-law concept: gross negligence is failing to show the care that even the most careless person would show in similar circumstances. It is not enough that you could have been more careful. The conduct must have been obviously reckless.
In payment services, gross negligence is usually linked to the duty to keep your passwords, PIN and one-time codes safe (Art. 75, item 3). A classic example is a PIN written on the card itself. In phishing cases the answer depends on the facts:
- how convincing the fraud was: a spoofed number, a website indistinguishable from the real one, personal details the fraudster already knew;
- what the text message with the code said: just a code, or a clear “payment of EUR X to Y”;
- whether you were under pressure and in what situation you acted;
- whether the bank had warned specifically about this kind of scheme and whether its systems flagged the transaction as unusual.
Is reading out a text-message code over the phone gross negligence?
It depends. If the “bank officer” called from a spoofed number, knew your details and told you the code would stop a suspicious payment, there are strong arguments against gross negligence. If, however, the message clearly described a transfer to an unknown payee, the bank will argue that you ignored an obvious warning. That is why you should never delete the messages.
The burden of proof is on the bank
Art. 78(1) of the Act requires the bank to prove that the transaction was authenticated, accurately recorded and entered in the accounts, and not affected by a technical failure. Art. 78(4) matters even more: the recorded use of the payment instrument is not in itself sufficient evidence that you authorised the transaction or acted with gross negligence.
A one-time code is an element of strong customer authentication (Art. 100), not an expression of your will to pay the fraudster. If the bank did not require such authentication at all, you bear no loss unless you acted fraudulently yourself (Art. 80(4)), and gross negligence is irrelevant.
What should I ask the bank for in order to challenge the refusal?
Ask in writing which authentication elements confirmed each transaction, from which device and IP address, what the exact text of the confirmation message was and whether the bank's systems flagged the transaction as risky. This information is held by the bank, and without it the bank will find it hard to prove gross negligence.
The EU Court of Justice: the bank refunds first and argues later
In its judgment of 15 October 2026 in case C-70/25, the Court of Justice of the European Union held that for an unauthorised transaction the bank must refund the amount by the end of the next business day, even if it believes the customer was grossly negligent. The only exception is a reasonable suspicion of fraud by the customer, reported to the competent authority.
Afterwards the bank may try to recover the loss from the customer, but then the bank is the claimant and must prove gross negligence. The ruling binds Bulgarian courts too, because the Act transposes the same EU directive. A detailed analysis of the judgment and of Bulgarian case law is in our article on gross negligence after phishing.
The bank refunded me and now wants the money back. What should I do?
Do not pay and do not sign an admission of negligence or a repayment agreement before the bank's evidence has been assessed. If the bank applies for a payment order, the deadline for an objection is short. What to do then is explained on our page received an order for payment.
How we challenge a “gross negligence” refusal
As a banking lawyer in Sofia, we build the claim around facts the bank will find hard to rebut. We usually work like this:
- A detailed timeline: exactly what you did and what you did not do.
- A request to the bank for its evidence and for the text of the confirmation messages.
- A reasoned complaint relying on Art. 78(4) and Art. 79(1) of the Act and on the case law of the EU Court of Justice.
- Representation before the Conciliation Commission for Payment Disputes (Помирителна комисия за платежни спорове) and in court.
- Your defence if the bank sues you or applies for a payment order against you.
What documents should you prepare?
- The bank's refusal and all your complaints and notices to it
- The fraudster's text messages, e-mails and other messages, including the link
- The bank's text messages with confirmation codes and their exact wording
- A screenshot of the fake website or your browser history, if saved
- Your call history, if you spoke to an “officer”
- A statement showing the disputed transactions and the police reference number
Who will handle your case
Frequently asked questions about phishing and gross negligence
Is a company account protected in the same way?
Not fully. Where the customer is not a consumer, the bank and the customer may agree that Arts. 78 and 80 of the Act will not apply (Art. 67(4)). The bank's terms and conditions then carry much more weight and the dispute is harder.
Does it matter that I did not understand the text message because I do not speak Bulgarian?
It may. This is an argument against gross negligence, especially if the fraud was in your native language. The bank may reply that you confirmed a transaction without understanding it. The court weighs this circumstance as well.
I installed an app the fraudster told me to. Is that gross negligence?
The bank will almost certainly say so. The answer depends on what you were told, what the app looked like and whether the bank had warned specifically about such schemes. Your position is harder, but not hopeless, if the fraudster ordered the transfer himself.
Can I still succeed if I deleted the text messages?
Deleting them does not take away your rights, but it makes proof harder. The bank keeps records of the messages it sent, so ask it for their exact wording. The mobile operator can sometimes provide a record as well.
Can I get the money back if I made the transfer myself on a fraudster's instructions?
Then the transaction is, as a rule, authorised and the immediate refund rule does not apply. Other routes remain: an attempt to recover the funds through the payee's bank, a police report and a claim against the person who received the money.
Related services
Have a legal question? Get in touch.
The initial consultation is free and without obligation.