Casco Claim Refused in Bulgaria

When your Casco insurer refuses to pay or values the damage far below the cost of repair, we check whether it has a lawful ground and challenge the amount.

In short

What can I do if my Casco claim is refused in Bulgaria?

We represent car owners and companies with vehicle fleets in disputes with Casco insurers in Sofia and across Bulgaria. We review the policy, the general terms and the insurer's calculation, prepare the objection and, if needed, litigate with an automotive expert report. The first consultation is free.

Casco (каско, comprehensive motor insurance) is voluntary, and its scope depends on the policy and the general terms and conditions. The Insurance Code (Кодекс за застраховането, КЗ) nevertheless sets limits: the insurer may refuse payment only in exhaustively listed cases, and compensation must match the loss actually suffered. The two most common disputes are an outright refusal and a valuation that covers only part of the repair.

If the damage was caused by another driver, you can choose between your Casco and a claim against that driver's insurer; see our page on car accident compensation. If you already have a Casco refusal or a low offer, call or write to us before you sign a settlement.

When can a Casco insurer lawfully refuse to pay?

The grounds for refusal are listed in Art. 408(1) of the Insurance Code: intentionally causing the event, a significant breach of a contractual obligation that led to the event, and other cases provided for by law. Insurers most often rely on a breached obligation, but the breach alone is not enough. The obligation must be provided for, the breach must be significant and it must have caused the damage.

The same logic applies to circumstances misstated when the policy was taken out. A full or partial refusal is possible only if the undisclosed circumstance contributed to the event; if it affected only the extent of the damage, the insurer may only reduce the compensation (Art. 363(4) of the Insurance Code).

Can the insurer refuse because I reported the damage late?

By law you notify the insurer within 7 working days, unless the contract sets another period, which cannot be shorter than 3 working days, or 24 hours for theft (Art. 403 of the Insurance Code). Late notice is a ground for refusal only if it was meant to prevent the insurer from establishing the facts or made that impossible. If the insurer learned of the event in another way, it cannot refuse on this ground.

Exclusions in Casco general terms

Apart from the grounds for refusal, the general terms list exclusions: risks that are not covered at all. They bind you only if they were handed to you when the contract was concluded and you accepted them in writing, and where they differ from the policy, the policy prevails (Art. 348(1) of the Insurance Code).

An exclusion must be clearly worded. In consumer contracts unclear clauses are interpreted in favour of the consumer, and unfair terms are void under the Consumer Protection Act (Закон за защита на потребителите). Whether a particular clause survives that test depends on its wording and, ultimately, on the court.

  • wear and tear, corrosion and mechanical or electrical failure without an external event;
  • damage to tyres and wheel rims only;
  • driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, or without a driving licence;
  • theft with the keys or the registration certificate left in the car;
  • old damage that was not recorded at the inspection when the policy was taken out.

My Casco claim was refused because the driver was drunk. Can anything be done?

It depends on how the clause is worded: as an exclusion from cover or as an obligation of the insured. That decides whether the insurer has to prove a link between the breach and the damage. So with such a refusal we first read the exact text of the general terms and then assess your prospects.

Casco damage valued too low: how to challenge it

The insurer owes compensation equal to the loss actually suffered on the day of the event, up to the sum insured (Art. 386 of the Insurance Code). In practice the dispute is about the calculation: missing parts, parts marked for repair instead of replacement, too few labour hours, or non-original parts for a car insured for repair at an authorised dealer.

If the sum insured is lower than the value of the car, compensation is reduced proportionally only if the contract expressly says so (Art. 389 of the Insurance Code). Check this before accepting a reduced amount; the same rule applies to home insurance claims.

  • Ask in writing for the calculation, the inspection photos and the reasons. After a complaint the insurer owes written reasons within 7 days (Art. 108(6) of the Insurance Code).
  • Get a quote from a garage and an opinion from an independent automotive expert.
  • File a written objection and ask for a further inspection of hidden damage.
  • Do not repair the car before the damage has been documented.

How long does a Casco insurer have to pay?

Up to 15 working days after you have submitted all the evidence (Art. 108(1) of the Insurance Code), and if you have not, no later than 6 months from the claim. After that the insurer owes statutory interest. A full table of deadlines is in our article Casco: when the insurer can refuse.

Total loss and car theft under Casco

A total loss exists when the necessary repair would exceed 70 per cent of the car's actual value (Art. 390(2) of the Insurance Code). The insurer then pays the actual value minus the salvage, or takes the wreck in exchange for full payment. The dispute is most often about the car's market value before the event, and sometimes about whether it is a total loss at all.

For theft, the general terms usually require immediate notice to the police and the insurer, handing over all keys and the registration certificate, and a document showing that a police case was opened. If the car is found after payment, you must transfer it to the insurer or return the compensation and reasonable costs (Art. 405(3) of the Insurance Code).

How do I prove the market value of my car in a total loss?

With listings and offers for similar cars, the service history, and details of the equipment and condition before the event. In court the question is decided by a court-appointed expert. The more data you gather early, the harder it is for the insurer to impose a low value.

Suing the Casco insurer

A complaint to the Financial Supervision Commission (Комисия за финансов надзор, КФН) can lead to an inspection, but the Commission cannot order the insurer to pay. The conciliation procedure before the sectoral committee at the Consumer Protection Commission (Комисия за защита на потребителите) is free, but its decision is not binding. If these routes fail, a lawsuit remains.

In court the decisive evidence is usually the court-appointed automotive expert report. The expert establishes which damage comes from the event, what should be repaired or replaced and what the necessary repair costs. As your insurance lawyer in Sofia, we frame the questions to the expert so that they cover the whole dispute.

How long do I have to sue my Casco insurer?

The limitation period is three years from the date of the event (Art. 378(1) of the Insurance Code). It is suspended from the filing of the claim until the insurer's decision, or until its deadline to decide expires (Art. 378(9) of the Insurance Code), but not throughout any later negotiations.

What documents should you prepare?

  • The policy, the general terms valid on the date of conclusion and the inspection report from when the policy was taken out
  • The accident report or police document; for theft, details of the police case
  • Photos of the damage before repair and, if available, the removed parts
  • Your claim and the insurer's calculation, letters and refusal
  • Garage quotes and invoices, and an independent expert's opinion
  • The car's service history and documents on its equipment

Who will handle your case

Frequently asked questions about Casco claims

Can I refuse repair at the insurer's partner garage and ask for money instead?

It depends on the policy. If you chose settlement through a partner garage, the insurer will as a rule insist on it. Repair in kind, however, requires your consent (Art. 406 of the Insurance Code), so read what you signed when the policy was taken out.

Does Casco cover damage from a pothole?

Usually yes, if the policy covers the accident risk and there is no exclusion for the parts concerned, for example tyres and rims only. After paying, the insurer recovers the amount from the municipality or the Road Infrastructure Agency (Агенция „Пътна инфраструктура“).

If I sign a settlement with the insurer, can I claim the difference later?

Usually only with great difficulty. A full and final settlement normally contains a waiver of further claims. Sign it only if the amount genuinely covers the repair, or after taking legal advice.

Does Casco pay if another driver was at fault?

Yes, if the risk is covered. The Casco insurer pays and then recovers the amount from the at-fault driver and their motor liability insurer (Art. 410 and 411 of the Insurance Code). The excess and any uncovered losses you can claim yourself from the at-fault driver's insurer.

Can the Financial Supervision Commission order the insurer to pay me?

No. The Commission can inspect the insurer and impose sanctions, but it does not award compensation. To compel payment you need a court judgment or a settlement.

Insurance Lawyer in Sofia

Have a legal question? Get in touch.

The initial consultation is free and without obligation.