In short
How do I appeal a court judgment in Bulgaria?
We draft appeals and responses to appeals against judgments of the district and regional courts and represent you before the appeal court in Sofia and across Bulgaria. We assess whether an appeal makes sense, which errors of the first instance to raise and what evidence can still be added. The first consultation is free.
A first-instance judgment is not the last word. The appeal court (въззивен съд) examines the dispute again, on the facts and on the law, and may decide it differently. The deadline, however, is short - two weeks - and the appeal must state precisely where the first-instance court went wrong. A general appeal along the lines of 'I disagree' rarely helps.
If you have received a judgment you are not satisfied with, or the other party has appealed a judgment in your favour, send it to us straight away. As part of our litigation work we also handle appeals, including the next step - a cassation appeal to the Supreme Court of Cassation. Call or write to us and we will tell you what your chances are and how much time you have.
Deadline for an appeal and which court hears it
An appeal is filed within two weeks of service of the judgment (Art. 259(1) of the Civil Procedure Code, Граждански процесуален кодекс, ГПК). It is filed through the court that gave the judgment, not directly with the higher court. The first-instance court checks the appeal, sends it to the other party and then forwards the case to the appeal court.
Judgments of a district court (районен съд) are appealed to the regional court (окръжен съд); in Sofia this is the Sofia City Court (Софийски градски съд). Judgments given by a regional court as the first instance are appealed to the court of appeal (апелативен съд). A state fee is paid with the appeal: half of the first-instance fee, calculated on the amount appealed. Use our court fees calculator for an estimate.
When does the two-week appeal deadline start?
On the day the judgment is served on you - in person, through your lawyer or electronically. The deadline ends on the same weekday two weeks later, or on the next working day if that day is a public holiday or weekend. A missed deadline as a rule cannot be made up. You can check the date with our deadline calculator, but if in doubt, ask a lawyer.
What an appeal must contain
The strength of an appeal lies in being specific. The appeal court does not search for every possible error on its own; it mainly reviews what the appeal points out. The appeal must therefore make clear which judgment is challenged, to what extent and why it is wrong.
- The judgment appealed and which part of it is appealed.
- What is wrong with it: facts established incorrectly, the law applied wrongly or procedural violations.
- What you ask the appeal court to do - set the judgment aside and uphold or dismiss the claim.
- New evidence and requests for evidence, if there are grounds for them.
- Proof that the state fee has been paid and copies for the other parties.
Can I appeal only part of a judgment?
Yes. If the claim was upheld in part, you may appeal only the dismissed part, and the other party only the part that was upheld. The part that nobody appeals becomes final. The fee is calculated only on the amount appealed, so defining the amount in dispute on appeal precisely also affects the costs.
New evidence on appeal
An appeal is not a fresh start of the case. New facts and evidence may be put before the appeal court only if the party could not learn of, state or present them before filing the appeal or within the time for a response, or if the facts arose after that (Art. 266(2) of the Civil Procedure Code).
You can also ask for evidence that the first-instance court wrongly refused to admit, for example a witness or an expert report (Art. 266(3)). When preparing the appeal we therefore also review the hearing records, which show what was requested and what was refused.
Can I submit new evidence to the appeal court?
Only under the conditions above. A document you had all along but did not submit will as a rule not be admitted. This is why evidence must be gathered carefully at first instance, as we explain on our page on civil cases.
What the appeal court reviews and what it decides
The appeal court checks on its own motion whether the judgment is valid and, in the part appealed, whether it is admissible. On whether the judgment is correct, it is limited to the arguments in the appeal (Art. 269 of the Civil Procedure Code). Within those limits the court assesses the evidence itself and may reach different conclusions on the facts.
The court may uphold the judgment, set it aside in whole or in part and decide the dispute itself on the merits (Art. 271). If the first-instance judgment is inadmissible, for example because it rules on a claim that was never brought, it is annulled. The case is sent back to the first instance only in the cases expressly provided for by law.
Can the appeal court make my position worse?
If only you appeal, the appeal court cannot give a judgment that is less favourable to you than the one appealed (Art. 271(1)). The risk changes if the other party has also filed an appeal or a cross-appeal, because the court then also examines its arguments.
When the other party appeals: response and cross-appeal
If you won the case and the other party has appealed, you will receive a copy of the appeal. Within two weeks you may file a written response (Art. 263(1) of the Civil Procedure Code). In it we rebut the appellant's arguments and support the correct findings of the first instance.
Within the same period a cross-appeal (насрещна въззивна жалба) may be filed (Art. 263(2)), for example if your claim was upheld only in part and you had decided not to appeal unless the other party did. A cross-appeal is not examined if the main appeal is withdrawn or returned (Art. 263(4)).
What happens if I do not respond to the appeal?
The case goes ahead without a response and the court will examine the appeal. You lose, however, the opportunity to set out your defence in writing and to request evidence on the appellant's new arguments. Where a significant amount is at stake, we do not recommend leaving an appeal unanswered.
What documents should you prepare?
- The judgment appealed and the date it was served on you
- The statement of claim, the defence and all applications in the case
- The records of the court hearings
- The evidence and expert reports submitted at first instance
- Any new documents or information you think are important
- The other party's appeal, if you have received one
Who will handle your case
Frequently asked questions about appealing a judgment
How long does an appeal take?
It depends on the court and its workload. After the appeal is filed, several weeks pass while the papers are exchanged and the case is forwarded to the appeal court. The appeal proceedings themselves usually take from several months to about a year.
Does an appeal stop enforcement of the judgment?
As a rule, the judgment does not become final while the appeal deadline is running and while the appeal is pending, so it cannot be enforced. The exception is a judgment with provisional enforcement, for example for child support or wages awarded. In that case you can ask for enforcement to be stayed.
How do I appeal a ruling rather than a judgment?
Rulings (определения) that can be appealed are challenged by a private appeal (частна жалба) within one week of service (Art. 275 of the Civil Procedure Code). Examples are a ruling terminating the case or refusing interim measures.
Do I need a lawyer to appeal?
The law does not require one - you may file the appeal yourself. The appeal court, however, mainly reviews what the appeal points out, and arguments and evidence left out as a rule cannot be added after the deadline. The quality of the appeal therefore often decides the outcome.
What if I missed the appeal deadline?
The judgment becomes final. The deadline can be restored only if you missed it because of exceptional unforeseen circumstances that you could not overcome (Art. 64(2) of the Civil Procedure Code). The application for restoration must be made quickly, within one week of being notified that the deadline was missed (Art. 64(3)).
Can the case end in a settlement at the appeal stage?
Yes. The parties may conclude a court settlement before the appeal court as well. The judgment appealed is then annulled and the dispute ends on the agreed terms.
Related services
Have a legal question? Get in touch.
The initial consultation is free and without obligation.