In short
Who is liable if I fall into an open manhole or trench in Bulgaria?
We help people injured by falling into open, broken or sunken manholes and unfenced trenches left by roadworks. Before the case we establish whether the municipality, the water company, the power or telecoms company, district heating or the building contractor is liable, and we conduct the claim for pain, treatment and lost income. The first consultation is free of charge.
After a fall into a manhole or trench, the right to compensation is usually clear. Cases are lost for another reason: the claim is brought against the wrong defendant. Networks belonging to different owners run under the streets, and a trench may belong to a company working for one of them. If you sue someone who is not responsible for the structure, the claim will be dismissed and you will owe that party's costs.
That is why the most important decision is made before the case. If you have been injured, call or write to us in the first days, while the place and the witnesses are still available.
Who is liable for an open manhole
The owner of the structure, or whoever must maintain it, is liable. Water and sewer manholes usually belong to the water and sewerage company (ВиК оператор), electrical and cable manholes to the electricity distribution company, those on heating pipes to the district heating company (топлофикация), and telecoms manholes to the relevant operator. Street gratings and unmarked manholes may belong to the municipality or the water company, depending on the network and the town.
The claim is civil, under Art. 49 in conjunction with Art. 45 of the Obligations and Contracts Act (Закон за задълженията и договорите, ЗЗД), and in some cases the courts also consider Art. 50, on damage caused by a thing. A case against a municipality is not brought under the State and Municipalities Liability for Damage Act (ЗОДОВ) but under the ordinary procedure of the Civil Procedure Code (Граждански процесуален кодекс, ГПК). The court decides the legal qualification; our task is to set out the facts fully and direct the claim correctly.
How do I find out who owns a manhole?
Photograph the cover close up, because many covers bear the company's logo or initials. Look around for a transformer station, a construction site sign or signs of recent work. We then send written enquiries to the municipality and to the possible operators and, where needed, a request under the Access to Public Information Act (Закон за достъп до обществена информация, ЗДОИ). We attach the replies to the statement of claim.
Falling into a trench during roadworks or construction
Several parties are usually involved with a trench. The contractor actually controls it and must fence it, mark it and, where needed, light it. The client that commissioned the work, such as the water company, the power company, the municipality or a private investor, may be liable alongside the contractor, depending on their relationship. The municipality must ensure safe passage along streets and pavements, including while works are carried out there.
Where damage is caused by several parties, they are jointly and severally liable (Art. 53 of the Obligations and Contracts Act). This means that if the court finds more than one defendant liable, you can recover the full compensation from any of them, and they settle accounts between themselves.
Who pays if I fall into a building contractor's unfenced trench?
Usually the contractor, but the client or the municipality can often be held liable as well. We check the site sign, the works permit and to whom it was issued, and only then decide whom to sue.
Suing several defendants: when it is worth it
Where ownership cannot be established with certainty, the claim can be brought against several defendants in one statement of claim, for example the municipality and the water company, or the contractor and the client. The court establishes in the case who is liable. You do not lose time on a second case, and the limitation period is interrupted against all of them.
The risk is that if the claim against one defendant is dismissed, you will as a rule owe that defendant's costs. An alternative is to join a third party to the case (Art. 219 of the Civil Procedure Code). If the defendant turns out to be the wrong one during the case, replacing it (Art. 228) requires the consent of everyone concerned and is rarely achieved in practice. That is why we make this decision with you before filing the claim.
I sued the municipality, but the manhole belongs to another company. What now?
The claim against the municipality will most likely be dismissed and you will owe its costs. A new case against the right defendant is often needed, if the limitation period has not expired. That is why we explain in detail how to establish the owner in our article on falling into a manhole or trench.
What you must prove and how defendants defend themselves
You prove the fall, the condition of the manhole or trench, who is responsible for it, the damage and the causal link, usually with a forensic medical expert report. The defendant must prove that it maintained the structure and, if it alleges it, contributory fault (Art. 51(2) of the Obligations and Contracts Act). Its most common arguments are that the hazard was visible, that you walked on the grass, or that you should not have been there.
The absence of lighting, fencing and signs at the trench itself as a rule counts against the defendant. So if the incident happened in the dark, photograph the lighting too, or return at the same time the next evening. If it was your car that dropped into a manhole, the logic is similar to pothole damage: see our page on pothole damage compensation.
Is compensation reduced if it was dark and I did not see the manhole?
Not automatically. If the place was unlit and unmarked, this usually counts against the defendant, not against you. Courts have rejected the contributory fault objection in exactly such cases.
Compensation, deadlines and how we handle the case
Compensation covers non-pecuniary damage, set by the court on the basis of fairness (Art. 52 of the Obligations and Contracts Act), and proven pecuniary damage: treatment, rehabilitation, aids and lost income. Statutory interest runs from the day of the fall (Art. 84(3)). The limitation period is 5 years (Art. 110) and runs from the moment the person responsible becomes known (Art. 114(3)). Where the owner is not known at once, the starting point may be disputed, so act within 5 years of the fall.
As damages and personal injury lawyers in Sofia, we gather the information on the owner and the contractor, assess the evidence and represent you against the municipality, the operator or the building company. An overview of claims over poor infrastructure is in our guide to suing the municipality.
What documents should you prepare?
- Medical records from the day of the fall and from the treatment
- Photos of the manhole or trench, the cover and any markings on it
- Photos of the lighting, fencing and signs, or their absence
- Names and phone numbers of witnesses
- Reports and enquiries to the municipality and operators, and their replies
- Sick-leave certificates and proof of income
- Receipts for medicines, crutches, rehabilitation and transport
Who will handle your case
Frequently asked questions about falls into manholes and trenches
Can I sue the municipality and the water company at the same time?
Yes. The claim can be brought against several defendants in one statement of claim, and the court will establish who is liable. If the claim against one of them is dismissed, you will as a rule owe that defendant's costs.
The cover was in place but tipped over under me. Does that matter?
Liability is not limited to a missing cover. A broken, loose, sunken or slippery cover is also a defective structure for which its owner is liable. Photograph the cover and keep the witnesses' details.
How quickly must the municipality answer a request for information?
The municipality must decide on a request under the Access to Public Information Act no later than 14 days after it is registered. Whether a particular company, such as the water operator, is bound by that Act depends on its legal status.
The manhole was covered with snow. Is the owner still liable?
The owner of the manhole may be liable, and so may the municipality if the pavement had not been cleared. Who exactly depends on the facts, so photos and witnesses from the same day are especially important.
How much does a court case cost?
The state court fee is 4% of the amount claimed, but not less than €25.56, plus the costs of expert reports and a lawyer. If you win, the defendant reimburses your costs in proportion to the part of the claim upheld.
The injured person has died. Can the heirs continue the case?
Yes. If the injured person dies during the case, the heirs can continue it. In one case against an electricity distribution company, the compensation was finally awarded to the injured man's heirs.
Related services
Have a legal question? Get in touch.
The initial consultation is free and without obligation.